Of two contesting models of social justice

Recently, in village in Bhojpur district, Bihar, which is dominated by Most Backward Castes (MBC), I heard a sohar (delivery music) sung by a couple of unlettered ladies. It goes, “Babua hamar DM hoyihe, okara upar CM hoyihe (My son will develop into a District Justice of the Peace and he may even develop into Chief Minister)”. I additionally heard a slogan throughout a political rally in Sasaram city, which fits, “Vote se lenge CM, PM, Aarakshan se lenge Collector, DM (I’ll develop into Chief Minister with votes and District Justice of the Peace with reservation)”. Each these expressions replicate aspirations for social justice. Additionally they present how the aspirations of backward communities turns into the essence of their politics. Collectively, these anecdotes illustrate how social justice is the driving drive in grassroots improvement and politics in Bihar.

In north India, for a number of centuries, the Bhakti motion challenged social hierarchies and promoted equality and inclusivity. However the street to social justice has nonetheless been lengthy and fraught. Leaders equivalent to Mahatma Gandhi, B.R. Ambedkar, Mahatma Phule, and Ram Manohar Lohia have had their very own visions and variations of social justice; these numerous imaginations proceed to co-exist in India.

Whereas in most components of India, the social justice discourse stays principally centred round Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, in Bihar essentially the most dominant social justice discourse is of Different Backward Lessons (OBCs). In line with the Bihar caste survey of 2023, OBCs and Extraordinarily Backward Lessons comprise greater than 63% of State’s inhabitants.

This isn’t new — Bihar politics has at all times been largely dominated by OBC politics. OBC communities, significantly the Yadavs, Kurmis, and Koirees, started rising as decrease and center peasants as a result of numerous land-based reforms carried out in each pre-independent and unbiased India. The leaders of those three communities shaped the Triveni Sangh in 1934 and started asserting their voice for political illustration. Different leaders echoed the aspirations of OBC communities in later years as properly. Other than the OBC social justice discourse, Bihar has different social justice fashions, which may be loosely categorised as Gandhian, Congressi, Nehruwadi, Ambedkarite, Lohiyaite, and the Bharatiya Janata Get together (BJP)-led social justice mannequin (samgra samajik nyay mannequin).

Bihar is about to go to polls later this yr. I’ve discovered throughout my fieldwork that the competition is about to happen primarily between two fashions. The primary is the social justice mannequin crafted by selective interpretations of the views of Ambedkar and Lohia. It emphasises caste-based historic inequality. The propagators of this mannequin are Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) chief Lalu Prasad, RJD chief Tejashwi Yadav, and Congress chief Rahul Gandhi. The RJD and Congress are a part of the Mahagathbandhan. This mannequin seems to be unilinear because it focuses on the demand for a caste census and the extension of reservations.

The second is the samgra samajik nyay mannequin. It combines the arguments of caste-based historic inequality with different types of horizontal social inequalities that emerged in the course of the strategy of distribution of democratic sources. The BJP, led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, promotes this mannequin, which mixes the visions of Swami Vivekananda, Deendayal Upadhyaya, and Ambedkar. In Mr. Modi’s e-book Samajik Samrasata, we might discover the traces of the evolution of this mannequin of social justice. This mannequin combines historic injustices with developmental injustices. It tries to deal with vertical and horizontal injustices confronted by marginal communities. Social justice seems to be a multi-pronged technique to counter backwardness of assorted types. Countering caste-based injustice is tied to beneficiary politics, which refers to the usage of authorities welfare programmes and advantages for focused communities. Beneficiary politics emerged via the implementation of assorted social help schemes for backward castes, Dalits, Adivasis, and ladies.

Thus, each the alliances have two totally different but overlapping social justice fashions. The distinction is that the BJP-led Nationwide Democratic Alliance has a couple of benefits. Each Mr. Modi and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar get pleasure from a constructive picture. However, the Mahagathbandhan is represented by Mr. Lalu Prasad, whose regime was perceived as corrupt. The picture of Deputy Chief Minister Tejashwi Yadav as a preferred youth chief doesn’t appear to have served as a counter-balance but. And the advantage of the caste census, which the RJD-led Opposition was advocating, has been minimised by the Union authorities’s announcement of a caste enumeration within the Census.

Badri Narayan is Director, Govind Ballabh Pant Social Science Institute